April 1, 2026
1 min read

Book Review: Julia

Sandra Newman’s Julia reimagines Orwell’s dystopia as a story about survival, autonomy, and the art of staying human.

There is something unsettling about reading a book when you already know how it ends.

That’s the tension running underneath Julia by Sandra Newman, a retelling of George Orwell’s classic 1984. You are not reading to find out what happens. You are reading to find out how someone lives when the ending is already written.  And that is a much more interesting question.

1984 is a novel about surveillance, control, and truth; Julia is a novel about survival.

In Orwell’s original, Julia is almost a symbol more than a person. She is rebellion, sex, impulse, danger, distraction. She is the thing that pulls Winston toward freedom and ultimately toward destruction. But in Newman’s version, Julia is not a symbol at all. She is practical. Observant. Angry in a quiet way. She understands the Party far better than Winston ever did and knows something he never really grasped: you don’t beat a system like this by rebelling loudly.  You survive by learning where the system isn’t looking. 

This version of Julia is not naïve about revolution, but she is not particularly interested in changing the world. She is interested in carving out small pockets of life inside it: food, sex, black market goods, moments of control over her own body and time. Her rebellion is not ideological; it is personal. It is survival disguised as pleasure. The world feels bigger, dirtier, more human. Less philosophical nightmare, more functioning dystopian economy held together with tape and fear.

Newman’s writing style fits this world perfectly. It’s clean, observant, and slightly detached; not cold, but controlled. The book builds dread slowly through logistics: food rations, work schedules, surveillance routes, shortages, favors owed, secrets traded. The horror of the world is not just torture rooms and Thought Police. It’s paperwork, queues, bad food, constant exhaustion, and never being alone. At its core, Julia is about autonomy. Julia’s greatest rebellion is not sleeping with Winston. It is the fact that she has thoughts, desires, and plans that belong only to her. The Party can monitor actions, speech, even facial expressions. But the last territory to fall is the private mind.

By the time the story reaches its inevitable ending, it doesn’t feel like a twist or a shock. It feels like gravity. The world of 1984 is still a world where it’s not the systems that break, it’s the people that do. And Newman doesn’t try to rewrite that. 

If 1984 asks, “What happens when a government controls truth?” Julia asks, “What happens to ordinary people who still have to wake up, go to work, eat, have relationships, and find some reason to keep living?” It turns out that question is much harder (and much more uncomfortable) to answer. 

This book is perfect for: readers who enjoy dystopian fiction with strong female perspectives, like The Handmaid’s Tale, Vox, The Power, and Red Clocks.

Ashley Elle

Ashley Elle is the Editor in Chief of theCITYSCENE and CMO of City Scene Media, where she oversees stories, design, marketing, and whatever else needs doing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Latest from Blog

Eastern State Penitentiary

When the Past is Still Present

Pennsylvania does not lack ghost stories. They collect in former prisons and poorhouses, in grand rooms built for parties that never happened, and across fields where thousands of men were killed or
The Serious Business of Play

The Serious Business of Play

At some point between childhood and adulthood, movement acquired a performance review. A bike ride became cardio. A walk required a step count. Dancing became a class, complete with registration fees and
Yesteryear Book Review

Book Review: Yesteryear

Picture Imperfect Caro Claire Burke’s Yesteryear turns the tradwife fantasy into a darkly funny, deeply unsettling examination of womanhood, influence, and the danger of romanticizing a past that never truly existed. Natalie
Pittsburgh Fashion

Rewrite the Dress Code

This fall, grown-up back-to-school style borrows the structure of a uniform, then adds better fabrics, sharper proportions and a point of view all its own. September retains its sense of ceremony long

Now Showing

Pittsburgh gives moviegoers more options than the standard multiplex experience. The city has tiny screening rooms, repertory cinemas, restored neighborhood theaters, a giant science-center screen and the last operating drive-in in Allegheny
Go toTop

Don't Miss

Yesteryear Book Review

Book Review: Yesteryear

Picture Imperfect Caro Claire Burke’s Yesteryear turns the tradwife fantasy
Klara and the Sun

Book Review: Klara and the Sun

Kazuo Ishiguro’s Klara and the Sun is the kind of